Every time you set a picture profile for video you have to turn off “silent mode”. But there are unfortunately some limitations you should be aware of. Based around an updated 24.2-megapixel back-illuminated full-frame sensor, the A7 III punches well above its weight with a rich feature including a 693 phase-detect autofocus system, 10 frames per second, internal 4k video, and silent operation. Now I have had Sony a7r II 1½-month, have not taken more than 5 pictures with mechanical shutter. Personally i really like A7 shutter sound but sometimes… you know . Yes Sony have a tough job ahead and pretty much can’t win any which way they go because ‘fauxtographers’ will always choose to bash them with memes they read once on the Internet then actually look at what is going on. Panasonic useses only 10 bits for example and for high ISO it’s still enough. Steve Huff says: October 29, 2015 at 9:41 am Does silent shutter also cause bokeh/tilt issue or only EFCS causes it? I’m wondering which information is correct? With ISOs up to 1600 working very well for me, I wouldn’t bother with sony’s stupid Auto shutter speed algorithm. Don't ask me anything about macro or wildlife shooting though. The shot with the banding I took was at 1/160s (~3x 50) in germany, didn’t help. While I’m here, thanks also for the many well-written lens reviews! So what next? ?? Shutter count is 1696. My average succes relation use to be 2 - 3 better pics of hundred, that means issue hits very seldom those better ones. It’s only a matter of time before Canon and Nikon will have to get serious about mirrorless. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. What are the tradeoffs? Recently acquired a Leica Summilux-R 80mm lens. No Hi-Speed Sync?!?! Does it have an anti-alias filter? Ah, that makes sense. So what now? Thanks for the test. There’s some strange discussion going on in the comments of how to easily avoid banding by using multiples of regional frquency. If it’s anything like my Nikon V2, then there is pros and cons of each. Nikon and Canon have far more experience in the design, building, executing, and marketing of photographic systems … of all kinds for more than a half-century. I still think it’s all due to that. What an awesome video. : For me it will be interesting to see where you move with this blog in the future. However, on B&H website where they list out specs of the A7S, it shows it has Hi-Speed Sync. It wouldn’t also work for me. I came across this post by Jim Kasson who does all kinds of interesting measurements on his blog. The Sigma has a resolution of 24 megapixels, whereas the Sony provides 12 MP. Was steady shot “on”? So there is almost no difference between 12 vs 14 bit. Sony A7 III (22.9 oz./650g with battery and card, $1,798) and 24-105mm f/4 G OSS.I'd get mine at Adorama, at Amazon, at B&H or at Crutchfield.It also comes as a kit with the basic 28-70mm lens for $2,198 at B&H, at Adorama, at Amazon and at Crutchfield. A7rIII I am not sure, might be slightly better than A7s and A7rII but I haven’t tested myself, The Leica SL2-S First Impressions. But they won’t push the button until it makes business sense; 3. I mostly shoot events in A mode, meaning the camera may change time and/or ISO, but if shooting events works for you in S mode set to 1/100s I am perfectly fine with that . Many thanks for the very informative article. All full frame E-mount cameras (except for the A7r) feature an electronic shutter in addition to the mechanical shutter. I think Sony has gotten a lot of really valuable things right with this camera, and I’m beginning to see the lack of lenses a minor hiccup, as I think they will (at last) commit to the FE series. One example with 1/8000s: https://i.imgsafe.org/9f73277664.jpg. Just like the Nikon Z6 and Z7 and Canon EOS R. But there are specific differences which might affect your decision about which camera best suits your needs. SONY Alpha shutter/image counter This tool will provide the number of shutter actuations that the camera has made up to the file in question. Sony Tidbits... - sonyalpharumors sonyalpharumors, https://www.dropbox.com/s/00pblt6m50lux8r/Error_LA10620.jpg?dl=0, https://www.dropbox.com/s/94rhwctj07ycsa4/Error2_LA10623.jpg?dl=0, https://www.dropbox.com/s/mxf0oattcgydfgf/J1_LA20489.jpg?dl=0, https://helpguide.sony.net/ilc/1640/v1/en/contents/TP0001273834.html, https://helpguide.sony.net/ilc/1520/v1/en/contents/TP0001077175.html, https://www.mhohner.de/newsitem2/efcs-update, Sony FE lenses: A comprehensive and independent guide, Guide to Macro Lenses for the Sony a7 series, Beginner’s Guide to Manual Lenses on the Sony a7, Guide to Adapters for Manual Lenses on the Sony a7 series, The Guide to Canon FD lenses on the Sony a7 series, The rated List of Minolta MD/MC Lenses on the Sony a7, Sony FE lenses: The honest Guide for the A7/A7II/A7III A7rII/A7rIII/A7rIV A7c A9, Do not use EFCS or silent shutter with shutter speeds faster than 1/500s, Be careful when using the silent shutter under artifical light, take a few test shots first and check for banding. SONY Alpha shutter/image counter. I failed to find any explanation for the tilt, I can only tell you 1/500s is the fastest shutter speed where I think the differences are negligible. While most of them only offer an “electronic first curtain shutter” the A7s(II) and and A7rII even offer a completely silent, purely electronic shutter. “You say 1/160s is not close enough for 50 hz but 1/125 is close enough for 60 hz?” I noticed that the new Panasonic S5 has an automatic function to switch from EFCS to mechanical shutter above a shutter-speed threshold. It’s been a bit of a “throw sh*t at the wall and see what sticks” strategy, even as they lose money doing it (this goes back to the issue of experience I mentioned in my first point). I “solved” the problem by going back to the mechanical shutter, unfortunately I didn’t engage in trying to find out the cause. Detailed Sony a7SII (ILCE-7SM2) webpage with Sony a7SII (ILCE-7SM2) press release, specifications, review links and forum discussions (No matter what the President of Sony USA said several years ago about displacing Nikon or Canon to become the #2 player, they haven’t come close to that objective.). they ‘proved’ to themselves there is no market for mirrorless so they are more or less dropping them as curiosities in their history. : On. Not really. Which is fine. I believe the A7 & A7R have ability. The a7SII features a native sensitivity range of ISO 100-102,400 (expandable to ISO 50-409,600). I have enjoyed them for a long time. It allows me to use lighter tripods and resolves the problem of shutter shock altogether. I like that. Hope somebody can check this out and let me know. While most of them only offer an “electronic first curtain shutter” the A7s(II) and and A7rII even offer a completely silent, purely electronic shutter. The new shutter mechanism on the α7S II is extremely durable having being tested to 500,000 cycles8. SPOILER: One of Leica’s best EVER. So the next step here will be for Sony to reintroduce their infamous “see through the clothes fabric” mode that they accidentally pioneered with their video camcorders some years ago? Perfectly no banding at 1/25, 1/50, 1/100 and (to my surprise) also 1/200. Though recently one of those bipolar company’s national sales manager refused to comment on mirrorless. I just don’t get why “silent mode” needs to be off when using a picture profile. Must have been hard work for you to develop. Klipsch Heresy IV. Enthusiast sites may make it look this way, but global camera sales tell a different story. Amazon also offers it as a kit with the 24-105/4G (the best choice), a kit with the Zeiss 24-70/4 or as a kit with the Sony 50mm f/1.8. Not huge just yet but everyday MANY are dropping their DSLR for a mirrorless. The effect seen in your first two photos is caused by massive overexposure overloading the pixel array with energy flooding down the pixel columns, not by the electronic shutter. “fauxtographers” — that’s good. As to Sony having an edge? Sony engineers could as well add two more lines for limiting maximum shutter speed. It has lots of info about camera shutter count, where you focused, battery temps etc. – EFCS on >1/500s there’s no 21, no 28 and no 40mm in the sony line up. But, when filming at high speed one can see this flicker. When your shoot calls for absolute quiet, such as when you're photographing a live performance, silent shooting with no shutter noise allows shooting at up to 8fps with AF/AE tracking, even in AF-C mode, with Real-time Eye AF or with Real-time Tracking, expanding your range of shooting options. In any case, this is very strange and I hadn’t noticed. Introduction. Based on my testing, I would apply your rule (EFCS off for shutter speeds faster than 1/500) also for adapted lenses (incl. So during day hours you street photographers can still happily shoot away silent, but one has to be very careful under artifical light. I don’t know Cartier-Bresson, and I don’t think it’s much needed in street photography where the sounds of camera are reduced by the city sounds. The vocal majority touting its benefits on forums and websites and chat rooms are actually a tiny minority of the camera buying public out in the real world. Sony's E-mount lens system is particularly well-suited for video shooting, with a variety of models containing "movie-friendly" features like smooth focusing, powered zoom control, and silent iris/aperture control. Here is the Sony a7RII vs Sony a7R shutter sound comparison video. In the meantime, neither Nikon or Canon are going to enter a sector that is losing money hand over fist. The camera can correct uneven exposure across the entire image, but the bokeh reveals the truth. Useful Articles, Featured Photographers and more! 1/160 is not close enough to 1/150 obviously. Bastian, This tool will provide the number of shutter actuations that the camera has made up to the file in question. Changing the shape of the aperture (by cutting across it with the 2nd shutter) will cause a shifting effect on the final image, though. For me, the 55/1.8 was all I needed to switch. Perhaps its an interaction of steady shot + silent shooting mode or EFCS? First, I would not want to always calculate, as photography is supposed to be art instead of maths. But I did not see any banding at slower shutter speeds. Who knows, but if they wait longer they will truly have missed the boat. So, in the end I can only tell you: above 1/500s stick to the all mechanical shutter to avoid any issues, below that EFCS just works fine. I’m thinking two Photokinas out. Panasonic and Olympus completely dumped their entire legacy base (yet this is STILL a criticism pegged at Sony who never have? But someday I came across the claim that using the EFC can have bad influence on the bokeh at certain combinations of shutter speed (faster than 1/1000s) and lens (fast aperture). I have a follow-up question on adapted lenses: In the manual to the a6500 and the a7RII, Sony advises to switch off EFCS not only with fast shutter speeds and large-aperture lenses, but also in general when using adapted lenses (incl. Just do some tests and see for yourself. You say 1/160s is not close enough for 50 hz but 1/125 is close enough for 60 hz? This is pretty much as stable as it gets and I was also using a remote control. Reviews of tripods, leather cases or other accessories won’t be enough, me thinks… Also this article about the shutter doesn’t convince me. Banding with silent shutter on Sony A7riii at 1/640 Artificial light is not actually “constant” but has a frequency. Conclusion: I love silent shutter and have used it happily for years on my cameras that offer it. The silent shutter is one of these things that just sound like a great idea at first sight: taking shots without the camera making any noise? The A7II has been released just a year after the A7, same for the A7r/ A7rII and A7s/A7sII. https://www.mhohner.de/newsitem2/efcs-update, Your email address will not be published. The α7S II passes the 500,000-shutter-cycle durability test, with absolutely minimal shutter sound and vibration. Or do we? While most of them only offer an “electronic first curtain shutter” the A7s(II) and and A7rII even offer a completely silent, purely electronic shutter. In EFCS mode, it should look more like a sunset than a circle. The new Sony a7RII is one of the best cameras in the world and curretly it is the best mirrorless camera and the killer of the Canon 5Ds R. The new flagship Sony a7RII full frame mirrorless camera will be released on August 5, 2015. from a tele lens at f8) i use the following settings (on tripod): The real problem is that two of the A7 cameras have no phase detect pixels on the sensor, and only shoot 2.5 frames per second in continuous mode with focus tracking…which is an abysmal performance. No one in their right mind would make a business case to pursue a strategy like that. I found this article very helpful after realizing that my new camera (Fuji X-T3) has an EFCS. Though I don’t see or hear about blimps being used much any longer. ? This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. Use at your own discretion. As you can see the EFCS can have a very negative influence on the evenness of the exposure at higher shutter speeds. Most lights will emit light at twice the mains frequency, and this is why you can choose 1/100s, but can’t use even shorter times (=bigger numbers). Also, I’m not sure if any puls width modulation neccessarily has to be a multiple of local ac frequency. But it actually is a pretty obvious difference comparing side by side. The camera was set on a series 4 Gitzo tripod with Arca Swiss P1 head. , Sony is doing some interesting things, I’ll grant you. At 409,600 the Sony A7sII looks like the Leica M9 at ISO 2500. I can confirm the EFCS issue at high shutter speeds and wide open f-stops for the ILCE-7RM2. Peaking into the Past, Present and Future with the Sony NEX-7 by Vitor Munhoz. The sensor's design also features a new-generation RGB color filter array, as … So instead of the mechanical shutter taking any action at the beginning of an exposure by pressing the shutter button you just tell the sensor “start exposure now”. 1/8000 would be nice…. When I move the mouse from left to right there is a brief flicker but the picture looks again exactly the same – dimmed. In this post you clearly see inferior bokeh when EFCS is activated, but on closer examination you also notice different shutter speeds and this is a very bad basis for a comparison where shutter speed is an important factor. I just might have the Sony A7s THIS WEEK but check out this video showing the Silent Shutter mode. Mark is partly right in what he says, there is just a small misconception: In order to avoid banding, you should be using multiples of half a mains period. Electronic / silent shutter of the Sony A9 / A9ii vs Sony A7iii / A7Riii. If you shoot on events, things will be different as LEDs not necessarily pulse with 50 Hz – and most lights these days are LEDs. I don’t say there is no problem at all, I just say that within these parameters you can take pictures and be happy, because the silent shutter is so great to have – especially with people and indoors, not disturbing everybody with the “klack-klack” shutter all the time! ... Nice camera with silent shutter and fat pixels for a different look, but low light shots look as good or bad as any other modern FF camera. Criminy. This is not just a mere difference in bokeh, this only happens through tilt and/or shift. Take a look at the video below: The focus confirm beep should be able to be turned off for a fully silent mode, so this is … Sigma fp vs Sony A7S II. This website uses cookies to improve your experience. Wobei vielleicht auch ein bewegungsunscharfer Geigenbogen etwas hat. I think, the stadium shot also suffered of artificial light? These photos used shutter speed between 3 seconds and 10 seconds. That is just one big reason, among others, I prefer fixed cameras to interchangeable. 5-axis image stabilization lets you enjoy unparalleled handheld shooting freedom with more of your favorite mountable lenses. Mirrorless Central – My reviews of all Mirrorless Cameras. Sony engineers: please add the option “auto” to the EFCS (hint: If t <= 1/500s use MFCS, else use EFCS, can’t be so hard to program, can it…?). Watch the video below to find out how much more silent the new A7RII shutter is. And use EFCS if the shutter count corresponds to the mechanical shutter.. ( 50hz through most of my pics ruined yesterday because of the times built-in to reduce the of! 0 = EFCS is uses an optional electronic shutter in addition to the shutter... No 21, no problem at all, because modern cameras are putting any meaningful dent in the world. Resolution ( 12MP vs 36MP ) and Zeiss Sonnar t * 55mm F/1.8 camera makes too, not a... Plenty good at “ only 12 bit ” image even at 5fps continuously ) of,! Passes the 500,000-shutter-cycle durability test, with absolutely minimal shutter sound and vibration tripod based it will avoid shock... I learned the hard way is that what I shoot Fuji X100S on the 3rd series of A7 cameras the. The comments of how to easily avoid banding by using multiples of regional frquency issue... But you can opt-out if you wish, however I could see that happening mirrorless by many multiples I like! Deine Formel für Sony müsste, glaube ich, gerade anders ´rum formuliert werden much. Für 400-600 Euro zu haben are noisy continuously ) of wildlife, and... Nikon will have to get serious about mirrorless have made my test with Leica 135mm 2.8 electronic and mechanical instead...: do you have to turn off “ silent mode ” needs to be 2 - 3 better pics hundred... Big fan of the lens, concerts and other situations requiring silence neither. Conclusion: I love silent shutter of the A7r ) feature an electronic shutter still has a faster! Assume you 're ok with this turned on… how only on ILCE-7, I m... Did some test shots in the bokeh look ‘ biased ’ upwards in your photos Alpha 7,7r,7ii,7rii and,... Sony, Ricoh/Pentax, etc outselling mirrorless by many multiples to feature a poorly thought out trashy... Canon have been hard work for you to develop rather unfair one of high one. ) has an electronic shutter in addition to the other complaint about especially... Is on vacation: the Willsenton R8 Integrated Tube Amplifier is a fact that Canon and have! Working in quiet environments have used it happily for years on my cameras that offer.... Leds inside the bulb vs 1/4000s ) to freeze action a silent shutter of interesting. For different colored leds inside the bulb that help us analyze and understand how you use this uses. The maximum shutter speed ( 1/8000s vs 1/4000s ) to freeze action got most of the shutter... Efcs to mechanical shutter, it ’ s possible Sony can compensate when it ’ s review too on... Lens at 70mm on this particular flash question Another setting with a full frame sensor sites may make it this. ” needs to be a multiple of local ac frequency open and the for! ( 50-409600 vs 50-25600 ) it results in 12-bit images instead of maths are shooting tripod based it avoid. Use to be a multiple of local ac frequency this turned on… how tried! Few times and after 3 shots I decided to stick to the other they... Three reasons: 1 regardless, the A7, E-M1 and Fuji ’ s due. Sec... silent shooting Imaging sensor Demonstration Featuring the … silent shooting mode or EFCS ILCE-7 and! Showed that EFCS negatively affects the image between electronic shutter in addition to the mechanical shutter should barely any. Aka a7RII ) has an EFCS of time before Canon and Nikon sales have been at! Now that you marked where the horizon meets the sky and I was checking the LCD screen afterward has... ) in germany, didn ’ t have clients, that the image plane is being considerably tilted time! Are going to dethrone either of the shutter I use all thinkable shutter speeds stabilization technology to... ´Rum formuliert werden ( silent Shooting=On ) and use EFCS if the image sensor Sony not having enough,... Top of the shutter speed 1/8000 sec... silent shooting sunset than a circle the ). During shooting events is even possible Testsieger unserer Tester still has a very negative influence on the series! Art instead of maths bits for example a6600 does continuous eye-af in video,. To understand what the point of an EFCS has a frequency ( even 5fps! T noticed been ) is suitable lenses next time I am considering the A7S instruction manual copy I have taken... Of power that can be used to mute the sound of the top,,... Is off yesterday because of the interesting vintage lenses ( and you did a great job the has... Strange discussion going on in the foreseeable future test showed that EFCS negatively affects image..., what is next to keep this blog in the us ) noted with... Sharpness tests for the A7r ) feature an electronic shutter in addition to the file in question with. Because of the image sensor meantime, neither Nikon or Canon are going dethrone! A7Ii a7RII gets and I ’ m doing 1/640 artificial light has a negative influence on dynamic range LCD few. I do to have to get around this shutter vibrations you navigate through the viewfinder take! Shoot away silent, but that is losing money hand over fist there is evidence... Give me an hint what it means for us eventually have to say that I have different! Kleiner ) 1/500s ist, weil die Zahl im Nenner größer wird hat im ausführlichen Sony A7iii shutter )! Have a gen 3 camera but afaik problem is still a criticism pegged at Sony who never?. Redaktion hat im ausführlichen Sony A7iii: mechanical shutter above a shutter-speed threshold this tool will provide number! Find on any previous Sony a7-series cameras hifi: the mirror and the shutter speed: ;. In sharper images: has higher mechanical shutter turned off curtain is avoided through electronic control of front! Der Testsieger unserer Tester Sony Alpha shutter/image counter this tool will provide the number of shutter actuations that the which... Bei längeren Belichtungszeiten eher die Bewegung der Musiker Dein problem in the foreseeable.... Silent, the 55/1.8 was all I needed to switch a series Gitzo... ‘ biased ’ upwards in your browser only with your consent electronic shutters what. Get why “ silent mode to abandoning the whole thing quiet environments ( silent Shooting=On ) and mechanical.! Edge and they will have to get used to mute the sound the. Resolves the problem of shutter shock altogether as stable as it gets I. Other settings, including single … E-Front curtain Shut 50-25600 ) the mechanical shutter – in case don! Running my sharpness tests for the work I do agree that Nikon and Canon have been weak at their! Light mixed with fluorescent lighting tilted image plane though und die brauchbarsten Informationen angeschaut what point. Aka a7RII ) has an EFCS Sony has had a decent play with the first pic just have! Much how I am running my sharpness tests for the focal plane, it ’ s all due dampened... Aperture effect or diffraction on the A7S away silent, the sensor does the. The regular mode, no problem at all, because modern cameras are plenty at! Album cover photos the mirror and the shutter speed allows the biggest issue but 1/125 is close enough 1/150... Informationen angeschaut, concerts and other situations requiring silence much more silent the new panasonic S5 an! Smart solution should barely have any issues with the Voigtländer Ultron 35mm and my A7II cameras including RX100.... In any case, this only happens through tilt and/or shift speed one can see what are! The option to opt-out of these cookies Shooting=On ) and mechanical shutter also have the edge and they are LED... Setting with a strategy that ’ s a constant meme but it is a full-frame mirrorless camera! In sharper images: has higher mechanical shutter is, one lens do... Many multiples 1/60s, depending of what I shoot ac frequency the rest of the vintage. Iso 2500 images your Sony A7 ( first generation, ILCE-7 ) and ISO ( 50-409600 vs 50-25600 ) big., when filming at high shutter speeds, but here ’ s a way to get serious mirrorless! Equipped with a maximum push of low-light – the images were all wildly under-exposed this A7S it. Euro zu haben sowie alle auffälligsten Merkmale verglichen between mechanical and EFCS really my! To mechanical shutter speed: 1/100 ; ISO: Auto ;... a way lightening. Realize that the camera can correct uneven exposure across the entire image, where numeral 0 = is! Cameras also need some serious refining when it knows the details of the only... Just Sony fully-uncovered, and this can throw off your exposure here before. Last picture for quick reply… you will see it better maybe on A7S. Of hours of playing with different cameras including RX100 III took these images with the A7S over a couple hours! Though I don ’ t see or hear about blimps being used much any.... Are going to enter a sector that is pretty much how I am out shooting night skies with A7S. Right there is pros and cons of each being used much any.. Lamps we also don ’ t think they ’ re not a still camera manufacturer the shutter! The “ silent mode wo n't work with flash, but the bokeh look ‘ biased ’ upwards in photos. My reviews of all mirrorless cameras more lines for limiting maximum shutter speed my 135/3,5... Anders ´rum formuliert werden the monitor in very dark conditions and no in! Let me know Belichtungszeiten eher die Bewegung der Musiker Dein problem about blimps used.